Best Home Warranty Companies for 2021

Choice Home Warranty

360 OVERALL RATING (4 out of 5)

MONTHLY BASE COST $55

ANNUAL BASE COST $50/month

SERVICE FEES RANGE $85

RESPONSE TIME 4 - 48 hours

Learn More

First American Home Warranty

360 OVERALL RATING (3.9 out of 5)

MONTHLY BASE COST $30

ANNUAL BASE COST $50/month

SERVICE FEES RANGE $85

RESPONSE TIME 24/7 hours

Learn More

Select Home Warranty

360 OVERALL RATING (3.8 out of 5)

MONTHLY BASE COST $55

ANNUAL BASE COST $54.17/month

SERVICE FEES RANGE $60 - $75

RESPONSE TIME Same day

Learn More

Why Choose

Choice Home Warranty:

Founded in 2008 with a contractor network of more than 15,000 service professionals, Choice operates in most states except for California and Washington. Unlike some companies, Choice assigns each service request a team of two or three representatives who follow the claim from start to finish. Choice offers some less-common coverages, such as for whirlpool bathtubs. Its service fee is about average at $85. For more information.

First American Home Warranty:

First American began 36 years ago and has some of the lowest monthly premiums among home warranty companies. It has two plans and offers additional coverage for improper installation repairs and building permits as needed for any covered repair. First American allows its customers to make unlimited service calls, which are available every day of the year, including holidays. It offers discounts to active and former U.S. military personnel and is available in 36 states. To find out more, check out our review of First American Home Warranty.

Select Home Warranty:

Select Home Warranty has been in business for eight years and is one of few companies offering no exclusions on certain items. It has one plan for appliances, one for systems, and a combination plan that covers both. Discounts are available if you purchase a new home warranty with Select. Depending on the time of the purchase, you can save up to $150 or get two months of free roof leak coverage. For more information, see our Select Home Warranty review.